Email securityPublished benchmark

You can’t see what your filter misses.

Your native filter catches the bulk. A 14-day, monitor-only trial shows what it misses in your own inboxes, then we match you to the platform that stops more.

Free. Live in 15 minutes, no MX changes.

The problem

Email is still the way in.

Email is the hub. Supply-chain conversations, hirings and firings, financial detail and strategy all meet there, which makes it indispensable and the most valuable target in your business. It has been the most common way in for years.

What has changed is the attacker's leverage. Finding the right target, researching them and writing a convincing lure used to take a person days. Now it runs automatically, in the right tone, with almost no effort. AI multiplied a threat that was always here.

More than halfof the breaches the ASD recorded in 2024-25 started with email.

Architecture

Where email is checked decides the outcome.

On paper, the leading platforms look alike. They differ in where in the flow they check your mail, and in whether you can see what your current filter lets through. Most teams can't.

  1. 01

    Native filtering

    Microsoft or Google's built-in layer. It is the floor most teams start on and it catches the bulk. It is not built to catch the targeted mail aimed at your people.

  2. 02

    Post-delivery

    An API layer that lets mail land, takes a copy, decides if it is dangerous, then pulls it back. High efficacy, but the message sat in the inbox first. That is a risk window.

  3. 03

    Inline

    An API layer that analyses mail before it reaches the inbox. Nothing dangerous lands to be retracted later. The same top tier, with a tighter architecture.

A monitor-only trial shows you. Within days it surfaces the malicious mail reaching your inboxes, including mail your native filter marked safe, so you choose on your own data.

See what gets through

What you get

What good email security gives you.

What safe email looks like once the architecture is right.

What to look for

What can the top platforms do?

Behavioural detection, attachment and URL scanning, and the AI behind them ship in every serious platform now. These are the capabilities that separate real protection from a box that has been ticked.

  • Visibility into what native misses

    A monitor-only view of the malicious email reaching your inboxes today, drawn from your own environment.

  • Coverage of all three mail flows

    Inbound, internal-to-internal and outbound, so a compromised account has nowhere to hide.

  • Inline analysis before delivery

    Mail assessed before it lands, not retracted after, so there is no window where a dangerous message sits in the inbox.

  • Click-time protection without the lag

    Links checked at the moment they are clicked, with no delay the user can feel.

  • Account takeover detection

    Behavioural baselines across historical mail flag a compromised internal account, not just inbound spam.

  • Protocol management in one console

    SPF, DKIM and DMARC managed alongside filtering, rather than as one more thing handled separately.

Maturity

Where most teams sit today.

Email security maturity, tier by tier.

  1. Focused

    Native Microsoft or Google filtering on its own, or a cheap add-on that can perform worse than the default. Self-managed, with no view of what is getting through. Many teams sit here.

    Typical features

    • Native Microsoft or Google filtering
    • Spam and known-malware scanning
    • SPF and DKIM set, DMARC monitoring only
    • Reported phishing handled by hand
  2. Broad

    A top-tier API platform layered over Microsoft or Google, watching all three mail flows, with account takeover detection and protocol management in one console. A strong base, working mostly once mail has landed.

    Typical features

    • An API platform over Microsoft 365 or Google
    • All three mail flows: inbound, internal and outbound
    • Impersonation and business email compromise detection
    • Account takeover detection
    • Malicious mail clawed back after delivery
    • DMARC enforced, managed in one console
  3. Best fit if you’re being targeted

    Comprehensive

    Everything Broad does, plus checks before mail lands and the same protection across Teams, Slack and SharePoint. The most room to adapt as attacks change, and the place to start if a fake invoice or a targeted phish has already reached your people.

    Everything in Broad, plus

    • Inline analysis before mail lands
    • Teams, Slack and SharePoint covered too
    • Warning banners inside risky messages
    • Click-time link checks with no felt delay
    • Threat intelligence shared with your SOC or MDR
    • Automated remediation across every mailbox

Tekspace Research

We tested the email security field.

We benchmarked the leading email security platforms against the same tests and published what we found, including where each one let mail through. Your shortlist starts from those results.

Published benchmark

Email Security

What does your filter miss once a message reaches the inbox?

Catches what Microsoft 365 and Google let through, before and after it reaches the inbox.

What we found

Catching today’s phishing takes filtering that keeps watching a message and what happens to it after delivery. Only a handful of products do that well.

Vendors assessed

  • Abnormal
  • Barracuda
  • Check Point Harmony
  • Cloudflare
  • Darktrace
  • Graphus
  • Hornetsecurity Vade
  • Ironscales
  • KnowBe4 Egress
  • Material
  • Mesh
  • Mimecast
  • Paubox
  • Proofpoint
  • Sophos
  • SpamTitan
  • Sublime

What we tested

  • Post-delivery link checks
  • Account takeover detection
  • Monitor-only trial in your tenant

Same tests on every product. The full scores are in the benchmark.

Read the benchmark

The Tekspace Fit Method

How we’d help you choose.

Five steps from the problem you have to the product that fits, each leaving you with something you keep.

  1. 01

    Understand

    For email security

    Agree what’s getting through, who it targets, and what fewer incidents would look like.

    What you get

    Problem brief. The agreed problem and what success looks like.

  2. 02

    Map

    For email security

    Your Microsoft 365 or Google tenant, the three mail flows, and who runs the platform day to day.

    What you get

    Environment map. Your tools, identity, users and constraints.

  3. 03

    Narrow

    For email security

    The platforms that suit your tenant and the way your team works, with a reason for every one we cut.

    What you get

    Shortlist with reasons. Why each option made it, and why the rest did not.

  4. 04

    Prove

    For email security

    A monitor-only trial on your own mail shows what each one catches that native misses.

    What you get

    Proof-of-value results. How each option did against your problem.

  5. 05

    Enable

    For email security

    Deploy, tune and train the people the attacks target. Then it’s yours to run.

    What you get

    Handover plan. Deployment, training and who owns what.

See our methodology

Questions we hear most.

63%drop in phishing-related IT tickets

“Engaging with Tekspace across our cybersecurity stack has been a game-changer for our organisation. We’ve seen a significant reduction in risk and a 63% drop in phishing related IT tickets.”

IT Operations Manager, engineering consultancy

Even where we have a product we like, we’ll recommend something else if your context calls for it.

  • No consulting fee
  • If nothing fits, we say so
  • Vendor-independent
  • Operating since 2006