Email securityPublished benchmark

You can’t see what your filter misses.

A 14-day, monitor-only trial shows what your native filter misses, then we find the platform that stops more.

Free. Live in 15 minutes, no MX changes.

The problem

Email is still the way in.

Email is the hub. Supply-chain conversations, hirings and firings, financial detail and strategy all meet there, which makes it indispensable and the most valuable target in your business. It has been the most common way in for years.

What has changed is the attacker's leverage. Finding the right target, researching them and writing a convincing lure used to take a person days. Now it runs automatically, in the right tone, with almost no effort. AI multiplied a threat that was always here.

More than halfof the breaches the ASD recorded in 2024-25 started with email.

Architecture

What keeps malicious mail out of your inboxes.

The outcome depends on when mail is checked and on the threat intelligence engine making the call.

  1. 01

    Native filtering

    Microsoft or Google catch the bulk before mail lands. Their threat intelligence is shared across hundreds of products, so some targeted mail gets through.

  2. 02

    Post-delivery

    A specialist API layer with strong threat intelligence pulls dangerous mail back after it lands. Until then, it sits in the inbox: a risk window.

  3. 03

    Inline

    A specialist API layer checks mail before it reaches the inbox, with a mature threat intelligence engine making the call. What it catches never lands.

Within days, a monitor-only trial on your own mail shows what each engine stopped and missed, including mail your native filter marked safe.

See what gets through

What you get

What good email security gives you.

What safe email looks like once the architecture is right.

What to look for

What can the top platforms do?

Every serious platform ships detection and scanning now; these capabilities separate real protection from a ticked box.

  • Visibility into what native misses

    A monitor-only view of the malicious email reaching your inboxes today, drawn from your own environment.

  • Coverage of all three mail flows

    Inbound, internal-to-internal and outbound, so a compromised account has nowhere to hide.

  • Inline analysis before delivery

    Mail assessed before it lands, not retracted after, so there is no window where a dangerous message sits in the inbox.

  • Click-time protection without the lag

    Links checked at the moment they are clicked, with no delay the user can feel.

  • Account takeover detection

    Behavioural baselines across historical mail flag a compromised internal account, not just inbound spam.

  • Protocol management in one console

    SPF, DKIM and DMARC managed alongside filtering, rather than as one more thing handled separately.

Maturity

Most teams stop at Microsoft 365.

Attacks are now automated, so most teams need the specialist layer that Comprehensive adds to Microsoft or Google.

  1. Focused

    Microsoft or Google’s defaults as shipped, or a cheap add-on that can do worse. Self-managed, with no view of what gets through.

    Typical features

    • Default Microsoft or Google filtering, or a low-cost add-on
    • Spam and known-malware scanning
    • SPF and DKIM set, DMARC monitoring only
    • Reported phishing handled by hand
  2. Broad

    Microsoft 365 fully configured, with Defender for Office 365 and DMARC enforced. The only view of misses comes from the engine that let them in.

    Typical features

    • Defender for Office 365 licensed
    • Anti-phishing and impersonation policies tuned
    • Link and attachment checks switched on
    • DMARC enforced
    • Mail flagged after delivery cleaned up automatically
    • Reporting only from the native console
  3. Recommended as your standard

    Comprehensive

    Everything Broad does, plus a specialist platform with mature threat intelligence that checks mail before it lands, across all three mail flows.

    Everything in Broad, plus

    • A specialist API platform over Microsoft 365 or Google
    • Inline analysis before mail lands
    • Specialist threat intelligence behind every verdict
    • All three mail flows: inbound, internal and outbound
    • Account takeover and email compromise detection
    • Click-time link checks with no felt delay
    • Teams, Slack and SharePoint covered too
    • SPF, DKIM and DMARC in the same console

Tekspace Research

We tested the email security field.

We put the leading platforms through the same tests, and published where each one let mail through.

Published benchmark

Email Security

What does your filter miss once a message reaches the inbox?

Catches what Microsoft 365 and Google let through, before and after it reaches the inbox.

What we found

Catching today’s phishing takes filtering that keeps watching a message and what happens to it after delivery. Only a handful of products do that well.

Vendors assessed17 vendors assessed

  • Abnormal
  • Barracuda
  • Check Point Harmony
  • Cloudflare
  • Darktrace
  • Graphus
  • Hornetsecurity Vade
  • Ironscales
  • KnowBe4 Egress
  • Material
  • Mesh
  • Mimecast
  • Paubox
  • Proofpoint
  • Sophos
  • SpamTitan
  • Sublime

Examples of what we test

  • Post-delivery link checks
  • Account takeover detection
  • Monitor-only trial in your tenant

Same tests on every product. The full scores are in the benchmark.

Read the benchmark

Questions we hear most.